Amateur Hour Is Over: A Record-Breaking Sale in 85020
A young family had to sell a home in an 85020 neighborhood they loved to make room for the family they wanted
A young family had to sell a home in an 85020 neighborhood they loved to make room for the family they wanted
A young Orangewood North couple with a new baby needed to sell the home they’d poured years of upgrades into, in order to afford a larger home for their growing family. We priced it $75,000 above any home ever sold in the subdivision, backed it with real preparation and marketing, and sold it for $720,000 cash, five offers in 48 hours, $145,000 above the previous neighborhood record.
They’d just had their first child and were hoping for a second. The home they were in, while one they loved, wasn’t going to give them the space a bigger family needed. They’d already found and purchased their next home, a larger one with a bigger price tag, which meant this sale wasn’t optional. It needed to work hard for them financially.
Why was this sale harder than a typical move?
They’d already closed on the new home before this one sold, which meant every week it sat on the market was a week of paying two mortgages. On top of that, they’d genuinely loved this house. They’d remodeled it, upgraded it, and built a life in it and in the neighborhood. Letting go of it was hard on its own, without the added pressure of needing top dollar to make the next move work.
What was their biggest concern going into the sale?
Maximizing the price. Since they’d already committed to a more expensive home, every dollar this sale brought in made the next chapter easier. They needed a result, not just an offer.
What made pricing this home difficult?
The highest price ever paid for a home in their subdivision was $575,000. Based on the comps alone, that’s where most agents would have started. But this home had more upgrades, and better ones, than anything that had ever sold in the neighborhood, and it sat on the largest lot in the subdivision. I recommended listing at $650,000, seventy five thousand dollars above any sale the neighborhood had ever seen. In a market where buyers have gotten more careful, that’s a real number to ask sellers to commit to. They trusted the strategy, and we moved forward.
Before it ever hit the market, we brought in our in-house staging consultant to get the home into its best possible condition, and our construction crew to handle paint touch ups and small repairs. First impressions decide a lot of what a home sells for, and that step isn’t optional anymore.
For the launch, we sent postcards to the 250 nearest neighbors and invited them to a private open house on a Saturday morning, coffee and bagels included, before opening the doors to the general public later that day. We also marketed the home ahead of launch through our email database of over 8,000 potential buyers, our brokerage’s 150 agents, and a network of more than 10,000 agents across the Phoenix market.
How did buyers respond?
The neighbor open house was a strong turnout on its own, and the public open house that followed brought over 45 groups through the home that same day.
How quickly did offers come in?
Five offers, all within 48 hours of going live.
How did the numbers work out?
The winning offer was $720,000 cash, seventy thousand dollars over our asking price, and $145,000 above the previous highest sale in the subdivision. It closed in three weeks.
How did the sellers react?
When I texted them the number, the wife’s reply was two words: “Shut up.” They were in shock. That sale gave them the room they needed to make their move up home work without the number keeping them awake at night.

Is it risky to price a home above every previous sale in the neighborhood? It can be, if the price isn’t backed by something real. In this case, the home’s upgrades and its position on the largest lot in the subdivision justified going well above the previous record. Pricing has to be grounded in what makes a specific home different, not just optimism.
Why did you hold a private open house for neighbors before opening to the public? Neighbors are often the most motivated audience for a listing. They already want to live there, and many have friends or family looking to move into the same area. It also builds early buzz before the home hits the general market.
Does home staging really affect the sale price? Yes. A staging consultant and light repairs before listing help a home show at its best from day one, which matters more in a market where buyers have more options and are comparing carefully.
What does it mean to market a home before it “hits the market”? It means getting the listing in front of potential buyers and agents through email databases, brokerage networks, and social channels before it’s publicly listed, so there’s already demand built up when it goes live.
Why does the agent you choose matter so much in today’s market? A sign in the yard, an MLS listing, and a few photos used to be enough. That’s no longer true. Getting a true top dollar result today takes proactive marketing, real preparation, and pricing built on what makes a home genuinely different, not hope.
About the Author Bob Hertzog, Your Real Estate Dad, has been licensed in the Phoenix market since 1999, bringing decades of local experience to every listing, sale, and client relationship.